Speech Talk
Speech Talk
Welcome to Speech Talk, a podcast for SLPs who are hungry to stay on top of the latest research but don’t have the time to read it. Every other week, join hosts Emily and Eva, two working SLPs who have taken it upon themselves to dive into the data so you don’t have to. Together, they’re turning clinical studies into real-life solutions. From cognitive screening to medication management, adult neuro rehab to discharge planning, they break it all down with evidence, empathy, and a healthy dose of sarcasm. It’s smart, practical, and very real. It’s also, ahem, your new favorite podcast!
Nov. 17, 2026

To Tuck or Not to Tuck? Making Sense of Swallow Strategies

To Tuck or Not to Tuck? Making Sense of Swallow Strategies
To Tuck or Not to Tuck? Making Sense of Swallow Strategies
Speech Talk
To Tuck or Not to Tuck? Making Sense of Swallow Strategies

This episode we examine evidence on swallowing compensatory strategies used to reduce aspiration and improve swallowing function. We explain how the chin tuck, Mendelsohn maneuver, head turn, supraglottic swallow, and effortful swallow are performed, and review findings on how they affect pressure, airway protection, and the movement of food through the throat in healthy swallows.We then discuss research on these strategies in people with neurological conditions, including Parkinson’s disease, dementia, and stroke. The findings include reduced aspiration with the chin tuck, increased oral feeding after the Mendelsohn maneuver in a small stroke study, and improved swallowing efficiency with a head turn in a small group. Other results were mixed: few participants with Parkinson’s successfully completed the supraglottic swallow, while a separate post-stroke study found that the effortful swallow helped clear pharyngeal residue.We also review findings in post-cancer populations. The chin tuck eliminated aspiration for many participants in one study, and the Mendelsohn maneuver was associated with increased oral intake. The effortful swallow produced the greatest base-of-tongue contraction and pharyngeal pressure among the maneuvers studied. Evidence for the supraglottic swallow was less favorable, and the reviewed cancer study did not examine the head turn.We conclude that these strategies should not be treated as universal recommendations. Their effects depend on the patient and the specific swallowing impairment, and much of the available research is based on small or limited studies. We discuss the importance of understanding what each maneuver is intended to do, selecting strategies based on the individual’s needs, and using compensations alongside efforts to improve swallowing function.

Key Takeaways

  • Many common swallowing strategies, such as the chin tuck and head turn, have a much smaller evidence base than many clinicians realize.
  • Understanding the specific patient population and underlying pathophysiology is crucial when deciding whether to implement behavioral swallowing strategies.
  • Research shows that compensatory maneuvers like the effortful swallow and Mendelsohn maneuver require careful clinical justification rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.
  • SLPs must critically evaluate clinical studies to bridge the gap between traditional dysphagia practices and current evidence-based solutions.

When should we actually use a chin tuck, head turn, Mendelsohn, supraglottic swallow, or effortful swallow? In this episode, we break down the evidence behind common swallowing strategies and discuss which compensations may help—and for which patients. Plus, we talk about what the research really tells us and why some of our “go-to” dysphagia strategies may have a smaller evidence base than we thought.

Citations

Ashford, J. (2009, November 2). Evidence-based systematic review: Oropharyngeal dysphagia behavioral treatments. Part III—Impact of dysphagia treatments on populations with neurological disorders. National Center for Biotechnology Information. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19533533/

Baraka, M.A.S., Sallam, Y.A.N., ElNeshwey, H.M. et al. Evaluation of effortful swallow in patients with post stroke dysphagia using visual analysis of swallowing efficiency and safety (VASES) protocol. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 283, 3325–3340 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00405-025-09920-w

Lee, Hannah & Rho, Hyunwoo & Cheon, Hee-Jung & Oh, Su & Kim, Yun-Hee & Chang, Won Hyuk. (2018). Selection of Head Turn Side on Pharyngeal Dysphagia in Hemiplegic Stroke Patients: a Preliminary Study. Brain & Neurorehabilitation. 11. 10.12786/bn.2018.11.e19.

McCabe, D. (2009, November 2). Evidence-based systematic review: Oropharyngeal dysphagia behavioral treatments. Part IV—Impact of dysphagia treatment on individuals’ postcancer treatments. Journal of Rehabilitation Research & Development, 46, 205–214.

Seo M, Park JW. Head rotation as an effective compensatory technique for dysphagia caused by unilateral cervical osteophytes. J Int Med Res. 2022 Aug;50(8):3000605221116757. doi: 10.1177/03000605221116757. PMID: 36036241; PMCID: PMC9434682.

Wheeler-Hegland, PhD;1, K. (2009, November 2). (PDF) evidence-based systematic review: Oropharyngeal dysphagia behavioral treatments. part II - impact of dysphagia treatment on normal swallow function.

Get in Touch: hello@speechtalkpod.com

Or Visit Us At: ⁠www.SpeechTalkPod.com⁠

Instagram: @speechtalkpod

Support: buymeacoffee.com/speechtalkpod

Part of the Human Content Podcast Network

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Frequently Asked Questions

When should we actually use swallowing strategies in dysphagia management?

Swallowing strategies should be chosen based on specific patient pathophysiology and supported by clinical evidence rather than relying solely on traditional 'go-to' compensations.

What does the research say about the chin tuck and head turn?

While frequently used in clinical practice, systematic reviews indicate that the actual evidence base supporting certain behavioral treatments and postural adjustments varies significantly across different patient populations.

How can SLPs apply evidence-based research to everyday dysphagia therapy?

SLPs can stay up to date by breaking down clinical studies into practical, real-life solutions that target specific neurological or post-cancer swallowing deficits.

Speaker1:
[0:15] Hi, everyone. I'm Emily.

Speaker0:
[0:17] And this is Eva.

Speaker1:
[0:18] And you're listening to Speech Talk.

Speaker0:
[0:21] We're your research book club so you can do evidence-based practice in practice.

Speaker1:
[0:25] So let's start talking. And we're going to start with your fun week, Eva. Tell me.

Speaker0:
[0:31] What was fun this week is that I went camping and I got to see the enormous redwood trees. And that was amazing.

Speaker1:
[0:40] Oh, that's one of my bucket lists.

Speaker0:
[0:42] They are stinking big, man. And we had like 12 people, five adults and a rack of kids. And we definitely could not get all the way around some of those trees. They're just crazy big. And I would say clinically, I had a patient ask for my contact information at discharge. She wanted to stay in contact. And I told her that I couldn't do that because of work rules, but that it made me smile and that it was meaningful to me.

Speaker1:
[1:15] Aw. I mean, like, I mean, clinically, couldn't you, like, keep in touch via email? Like, not, like, coffee grabs?

Speaker0:
[1:24] My work email. I was like, you can contact me, but it has to be through work. Like, I can't, I can't come hang out, but I would love to hang out. Ideally, we're sipping tea together playing Scrapple.

Speaker1:
[1:37] That's cute.

Speaker0:
[1:37] Yeah, that's really nice. How about you, Ems? What was fun this week?

Speaker1:
[1:41] This really weird thing happens to me that whenever I work too many hours, I get strep throat. I got it.

Speaker0:
[1:51] That's not funny at all. That's travesty.

Speaker1:
[1:54] No, it's terrible. It's terrible. So a couple of weeks ago, we were doing that fun thing. We're like, how many hours did you work? And it was like 11 hours. And then I got strep the next day. So my doctor sent me to an ENT. so guess who finally has had a fees

Speaker0:
[2:14] Oh you finally got a fees done oh that's exciting do you have like a a secret pocket where your strep lives and then when you're stressed it comes out.

Speaker1:
[2:25] Apparently but she didn't see it it wasn't like labeled so

Speaker0:
[2:30] Got it didn't have like a little mailing address home of emily's stress strep throat.

Speaker1:
[2:37] You're gonna send osmosis jones in there to go get it.

Speaker0:
[2:41] That's a throwback.

Speaker1:
[2:42] But it was weird.

Speaker0:
[2:45] Tell me about it.

Speaker1:
[2:47] I was not expecting that feeling. It felt like a really awkward, bloody nose. And I always tell my patients, it's like a COVID test, but whereas when I'm a liar, apparently, that's not how it feels at all. And now I'm like, do I even want to put my patients through this? This is terrible.

Speaker0:
[3:10] It's quite uncomfortable. It's... I really just tell people it is uncomfortable, but it's short. Like, it's one of the quicker procedures you'll ever have.

Speaker1:
[3:23] Like, I would definitely compare that to a pap smear.

Speaker0:
[3:29] In terms of things you're not trying to do this week.

Speaker1:
[3:32] Right.

Speaker0:
[3:33] Fees and pap smears.

Speaker1:
[3:36] They are the same. Different holes, but the same.

Speaker0:
[3:44] And for both ends this week.

Speaker0:
[3:48] Well, speaking of things we're going to get into this week, here are some speech bulletins. And I hope that was a salient transition from the Journal of Communication Disorders. Patients found telehealth speech therapy was nearly as good as in-person care and cheaper. But about four in 10 still want the in-person option. So there's still space for us to meet people face to face. And from the Journal of Voice, experts reached consensus on a new six-part speech therapy protocol for cervical spinal cord injury after tweaking exercise dosage guidelines. More on that when we become a real show. And as always, if you like getting headline updates like these, check out Medlines. It's another podcast from our network, Human Content, with headlines each week from what's happening in medicine.

Speaker1:
[4:44] So on to this week.

Speaker1:
[4:49] This week we are talking about the various prescriptions slash postures we tell our patients to do to help reduce aspiration.

Speaker0:
[4:57] As in maneuvers.

Speaker1:
[4:58] As in maneuvers. Compensations. So I wanted to get into this because so often, and no hate on nurses, but I will hear a nurse tell a patient, tuck your chin, it'll help. and it's like really are we are we helping so and

Speaker0:
[5:19] It is a big question i had a colleague one time an ot tell me that they always give a chin tuck like a recommendation for their swallow patients and i want to be like get out of my field and, and uh so no i think it's worth discussing because i I think a lot of people go, oh, someone has dysphagia, difficulty swallowing, just chin tuck. It'll help. So the big question is, does it?

Speaker1:
[5:45] Does it? So, yeah, that is what we are getting into this week. And now we will be getting into a brief interruption because apparently even podcasts need compensatory strategies.

Speaker0:
[6:02] So this week, we are getting into an evidence-based set. Hold Your Horses, not a single article, a trio of articles. Because when Emily goes in the rabbit hole, she goes hard. They were published together, though, under the umbrella title, Evidence-Based Systematic Review, Oropharyngeal Dysphagia Behavioral Treatments. So three articles, three kind of different angles, same review.

Speaker1:
[6:28] Right. But so the first, there's actually five articles in this set, but we're only looking at the three of them.

Speaker0:
[6:39] It was actually more and we spared you.

Speaker1:
[6:42] Yes, we spared you. The first article was examining a healthy swallow by Karen Wheeler Heglund et al.

Speaker0:
[6:54] Nailed that name.

Speaker1:
[6:56] I think I did.

Speaker0:
[6:57] I think you did. Spot on. Thanks, Karen.

Speaker1:
[7:02] It's a very Karen name. I could do a very Karen name.

Speaker0:
[7:05] Okay. So before we get into it today, what we're going to be doing with these three amazing articles that Emily found is taking a look at what the compensatory strategies do for different clinical populations. So the first one, what happens when you use a swallow compensatory strategy with a healthy swallow? Next, we're going to be seeing how does it work? How do those same compensatory strategies work with neurological patients? And finally, we're going to be looking at what do those exact same five do in post-cancer patients?

Speaker1:
[7:41] So we're looking at a healthy swallow. And the very specific conditions that we're looking at are... Very specific compensations that we'll be talking about today are the chin tuck, Mendelssohn, superglottic swallow, head rotation, and an effortful swallow.

Speaker0:
[8:00] I just want to jump in there, Emily. For people who don't know what a compensation is, it means it's actually quite straightforward. If you have a swallow impairment, you are compensating for it. So how are we adjusting your swallow to make it more functional?

Speaker1:
[8:13] Like Eva said, we're doing something to help the swallow, but the swallow problem is still very much present. The swallow problem is not going away. We're just band-aiding it with these different things.

Speaker0:
[8:26] One of those is the chin tuck.

Speaker1:
[8:30] So Eva, why don't you go into all of these techniques and how we use them?

Speaker0:
[8:37] All right. Number one, we got the chin tuck. What are you going to do? You're going to tuck your chin. You're going to bring your chin down and keep your chin down as close to your sternum as you can while you swallow. Next, we've got the Mendelssohn maneuver. And you're going to lift your larynx up by holding it up right before your swallow is initiated. So if you like mentally just close your eyes, try and swallow, you can feel your larynx or your Adam's apple going up and back down. Try and hold it at that up high posture. That's your Mendelssohn maneuver. Not easy. There's a lot of body mindfulness in that. Number three, we got the head rotation. Guess what? You're rotating your head side to side. Ideally, your chin is kind of getting close to parallel to your shoulders if you can. And normally we're going towards the weak or the impaired side. And number four, the supraglottic swallow. You're closing your airway before attempting your swallow, just essentially by holding your breath. And sometimes if you're super advanced, you can do the super, super, supraglottic swallow. Say that 10 times fast. And that is where you do the same exercise, but wearing a superhero cape.

Speaker1:
[9:54] No, just kidding.

Speaker0:
[9:56] But it is a thing and you essentially do the exact same exercise, but you cough afterwards. You cough after the swallow is done. And then number five, your effortful swallow. I like to say just imagine that you're swallowing an entire grape. Emily says try to imagine swallowing peanut butter, which really should be my thing because of how much peanut butter I eat. But whatever you visualize, you need to think about just swallowing as hard as you can.

Speaker1:
[10:22] Yeah, that is all of the compensation. So what happens in a normal throat when we apply these compensations?

Speaker0:
[10:32] And for grad school trivia, it's coming in hot.

Speaker1:
[10:38] So this is looking at, again, all those compensations that you don't necessarily need because your swallow is just fine. so your chin tuck when you tuck your chin to your chest to your sternum when you swallow with a healthy swallow you still have increased pharyngeal contraction pressure the duration of your pharyngeal contraction pressure is longer larynx to high um bone distance is shortened so overall you are using a lot more muscular effort and pushing that food down more efficiently lead.

Speaker0:
[11:15] Okay, so just like a little translation, you're basically squeezing your throat musculature to move your vocal folds out of the way. And then it kind of shrinks the space at which, you know, material could potentially get into the airway.

Speaker1:
[11:35] So when you're putting your chin down, it's already moving those muscles closer together. So then you're just pulling them forward even more. So it's doing even more than just kind of closing off the airway, but it does block off that airway a bit. Your next one, the Mendelssohn. So for this one, we see increased peak pharyngeal contraction pressure. So a big jump in how much your throat is closing and squeezing. There's a longer opening of your UES or that upper esophageal sphincter. and the duration of the contraction is increased and the time it takes for your swallow to go from your mouth into your esophagus is shortened. Diva translation?

Speaker0:
[12:27] Basically, you're like propping up your larynx and holding it there. And you're trying to keep your upper esophageal sphincter open longer. And that allows things to move through it.

Speaker1:
[12:42] Eh?

Speaker0:
[12:43] Eh. And I mean, the main reason that we really want to be doing the Mendelssohn maneuver is that if you are essentially unable to pass through it or have difficulty passing through it, food or bolus, through your pharynx and into your esophagus. One of the reasons can be is that that upper esophageal sphincter, the mechanism by which it opens and closes is impaired. So we want to give your body like more space and time to allow food to go through into your esophagus.

Speaker1:
[13:16] Mm-hmm. The next one they looked at, again, in healthy individuals, was the head turn. So you're putting your chin over top of one of your shoulders. Typically, you're rotating your head towards the weaker side. And they used a manometry, so a pressure sensor in your throat to look at this. And what they found was that there was increased varyngeal contraction pressure at the level of the vollecula and piriform sinuses. So all the way down, you are getting higher pressure. The UES resting pressure was lowered, so it's not as tight when you're going to swallow. It increased the UES anterior to posterior opening diameter, so bigger hole for food to go down, and then unilateral bolus flow to the side opposite the head rotation. So all the food that might have been stuck on one side is going to the other side, so it goes down.

Speaker0:
[14:16] Yeah. Okay. So while Emily sounds really smart, I'm going to say it as in a normal swallow, in a healthy swallow, there's pressure in all sides of your pharynx when you swallow moving things down. And if something gets impaired, it can be weaker on one side. So we're trying to recreate the appropriate pressure to move things through your pharynx. And when you want to sound super academic, you should say things like increased UES anterior-posterior opening diameter, and that is the sound of research.

Speaker1:
[14:50] Basically, just saying that your UES is bigger. You made a hole bigger by turning your head.

Speaker0:
[14:57] Open your sphincter, something I've never told any of my friends to do.

Speaker1:
[15:02] The next one they are looking at was the supraglottic swallow. So the idea here is probably the simplest one. We can't get more basic than this, but you're closing off your airway while swallowing. it also happens to prolong the hyalaryngeal excursion. So the amount of time your throat is being held forward for your swallow. If your throat is out of the way while you swallow, food should go down better.

Speaker0:
[15:33] Yeah. If you thought the things just moved up and down, you're wrong. They also move forward.

Speaker1:
[15:40] And the last one, my least favorite, effortful swallow

Speaker1:
[15:45] Least favorite i just don't i just don't get it i i need all the things to get it so this one was funny to me because the review showed that some studies had no or conflicting results on techniques and think it's funny because it is so difficult to describe and conceptualize to swallow hard. But they overall showed that the results did agree and showed that the effortful swallow increases lingual pressures, the duration of the lingual, pharyngeal, and UES relaxation pressures, so everything is relaxing more quickly, and the duration of laryngeal displacement, that forward movement was increased. But overall, it showed a lot of positive, positive things whenever we look at compensations in a normal swallow. In every single one of these aspects we looked at, pressures increased, the amount of time the bolus takes to go down was increased,

Speaker1:
[16:50] Your UES opening was longer, better, bigger. So in this case part of this set, this trio set of research, it's promising, right? All of these things that we're looking at says, yes, if this is happening in a normal swallow, why wouldn't it be helpful in other types of swallows? So then now we go to the impaired.

Speaker0:
[17:17] So it sounds like what you're saying is in this initial article, we're looking at all of the things that your body should be doing during a proper swallow. and here's all the ways in which we're measuring it right like here's like, the different types of pressure here are the ways that like the musculature is moving and here are what those compensatory strategies are supposed to be doing for your swallow is that right.

Speaker1:
[17:47] But it's not that these are the these are what it's supposed to be doing this is what the research found that happens when we do these. So they researched swallows, they measured swallows, they found that swallows do these things. So under different electromonography, under different swallow studies, when using these for normal people, this is what they found. Increased pressure, speed was increased, everything looks great.

Speaker1:
[18:20] Next up, we have John Ashford with the part three, with how these compensations affect those who have neurological conditions. Eva, can you tell us the populations that we're looking at?

Speaker0:
[18:32] Yeah, sorry. I was just waiting for the cough. Okay. Yes. So our clinical populations, we got a bunch of people. We got Parkinson's with and without dementia, making up just under half of participants. Dementia alone, another 43%. Stroke, 6%. Cerebellar ataxia, 3%. Head injury, 1%. And then just a small smattering of people with things like motor neuron disease, MS, depression at around 1%. So mostly Parkinson's and dementia.

Speaker1:
[19:06] So again, this is a series. So they looked at all of the same maneuvers mostly, but it is a systematic review. So they're pulling out data. And I want to start by pointing out that like reiterating what Eva said, 43% of this population that they looked at had dementia. That is a large portion of this study that has dementia as their main neurological condition. And some of these other studies just had like really low numbers of participants.

Speaker0:
[19:43] Yeah. I mean, it's actually more than the 43% because the Parkinson's was with and without dementia. So some portion of the Parkinson's patients also have dementia.

Speaker1:
[19:51] Yeah, so this is heavily skewed into the dementia bucket.

Speaker0:
[19:57] My favorite bucket.

Speaker1:
[19:59] I know. So keep that in mind, the Chin Tuck. This one was reported to have an eliminated aspiration in 15 out of 30 participants. And then the large-scale randomized controlled trial, comparing the Chin Tuck. So in another part, they were comparing the use of a chin tuck with thin liquids versus thickened liquids alone with no chin tuck. And about 33% of those people stopped aspirating after that. So in this study, it was successful.

Speaker0:
[20:32] Yeah, basically 30% of people stopped aspirating with a chin tuck. Dope. Great.

Speaker1:
[20:38] That's good. The next one was the Mendelssohn. And in this one, they were looking at mostly people who had a stroke. This one was interesting because before treatment, 20 of the 25 participants were dependent on tube feeds. And by using the Mendelssohn, about 55% had progressed to total oral feeding. So that's a good amount too.

Speaker0:
[21:06] Holy smokes. That is really good getting up to oral feeding.

Speaker1:
[21:10] Yeah. Yeah. But again, still very small amount of people. 25 participants overall in that study. It's super small.

Speaker0:
[21:19] Yeah.

Speaker1:
[21:19] Right.

Speaker0:
[21:20] And that's tough because it's like 80% of participants.

Speaker1:
[21:24] Yeah.

Speaker0:
[21:25] That's really like 20 people. But hey, for those 20 people, they went from like not being able to safely feed by mouth to... eaten regularly so good quality of life leap for for those 20 people.

Speaker1:
[21:42] Well no out of those 20 people out of the 25 people 20 of them had a tube feed

Speaker0:
[21:48] 80 percent were dependent on tubes right and then 55 percent went all the way up to oral feeding so 10 yeah or less wait math uh hold on i can Ten and a half.

Speaker1:
[22:02] Ten and a half people.

Speaker0:
[22:04] Ten and a half people. Yes, that's right. Sorry for that half person. This is one of those things my husband's always telling people that I'm actually good at math because of my GRE score. And then I do something like this and I'm like, no.

Speaker1:
[22:18] I haven't thought about my GRE score since applying to graduate school. The one thing I had to do to getting to grad school. Anyway, so going on to the head turn. So Eva, when you think about recommending a head turn, what is the population that you're normally thinking about the head turn for?

Speaker0:
[22:35] I have rarely had the opportunity to do it, but a lot of times it was people who post-stroke had severe like unilateral symptoms. impairments like on one side there's like body flaccidity or spasticity was just terrible right um yeah so i would say post-stroke.

Speaker1:
[22:59] So in this study they were looking at people who had lateral medullary syndrome um i don't think i said that right but that's okay and

Speaker0:
[23:10] I think you did medullary medullary i.

Speaker1:
[23:15] Don't medullary

Speaker0:
[23:16] You know how to say the adjective form of medulla call us um.

Speaker1:
[23:21] So they looked at that population and in that population they estimated the amount of bolus swallow improved from an average of 33 percent with the head in neutral position to 65 percent with the head rotation to the weak side so overall efficiency was increased but again this This was doubling,

Speaker0:
[23:41] Right?

Speaker1:
[23:42] Right.

Speaker0:
[23:42] They went from 33 to 65. Or is my math wrong again?

Speaker1:
[23:46] No, yeah, no, that was good. It is 32, but fine. That's five patients and not even talking about stroke patients. So I dug deeper. Our original article, it was out of 2009. So I found a different study in 2018 from Lee et al. who found that a head turn had no clinical benefit for improving dysphagia in hemiplegic stroke patients. And again, small cohort study. This is not like a strong study, but 20 is a good amount more than 5, so... And this is, I thought this was really interesting because when I was looking up compensations, I was going to talk about this later, but for this, I felt really strongly about because this is something that I had recommended to people all the time. And when I was looking up swallow compensations, anytime I saw any kind of blog or research or, you know, like some kind of article that describes compensation, these articles were the ones listed. And then in the research itself, it was recommending them with people who have this one-sided weakness. And not until 2018, nine years later, that they're like, this might not work for the population that we've actually been generalizing it to.

Speaker0:
[25:09] Oh, it's been generalized. Okay, I see what you're saying. Well, what's also just cracks me up about, reading research is that you end up with getting so used to doing these recommendations and you're like oh it has research articles cited and then you find out that the original, research was done on a five-person study that's not like overwhelming evidence great i'm glad that they found something there but certainly needed to be built on and it wasn't built on, for like over a decade.

Speaker1:
[25:43] Yeah that i could find that was open research. Again, all of our episodes are always going to be open research because we're not paying for them.

Speaker0:
[25:53] Yeah, free research, baby.

Speaker1:
[25:54] We also don't expect you as listeners to be paying for the research. So... not going to pay for something and then talk about it when nobody else is going to have it. But yeah, having something come back nine years later, that's like accessible. That's even a long time that we're still recommending these things. And I mean, 2018 wasn't even, you know, a short time ago. And I didn't see, yeah, I didn't, I was, I started school actually, because that's when my oldest son was born. So I started graduate school in 2018, and I still learned that I should be doing a head turn to the side for stroke patients when more recent research was out that maybe this is not an applicable compensation for a stroke patient.

Speaker0:
[26:42] And thereby contributing to everyone's imposter syndrome. What do we even know? What are we doing? What does the field say? Is there a field?

Speaker1:
[26:50] Yeah. So moving on, moving on, got to the supraglottic swallow. So results from this study revealed that one out of 12 participants with Parkinson's, this one only looked at Parkinson's, successfully executed the maneuver and subsequently eliminated aspiration.

Speaker0:
[27:11] So basically almost nobody could actually pull it off correctly. It's just, is it because it's like hard to sequence or coordinate? One in 12 is not a lot.

Speaker1:
[27:22] No, 1 in 12 is not a lot.

Speaker0:
[27:24] And 12 isn't a lot.

Speaker1:
[27:25] 12 is not a lot. And it was a research, so I don't remember specifically what they had said. Was there hindrance? But it could, I mean, it could be cognition. It could be the actual effort of doing it. It could be the fact that you're asking someone who is impaired to do this effortful thing every single time. I mean, who knows? I don't know. Yeah.

Speaker0:
[27:51] It's honestly a tricky one, period, to do the supraglottic swallow. And then we also think about, like, Parkinson's presentation. Depending on how progressed they are, they may have reduced motor control, right? So you're asking them to try to do something that they may, even if they can conceptualize it appropriately, may physically struggle to perform.

Speaker1:
[28:15] So again, this one only looked at Parkinson's disease. I pulled another article. Classic. I know.

Speaker0:
[28:23] Because your three articles weren't enough this week.

Speaker1:
[28:26] No, there's, I think because of all this back and forth, there's probably like eight. But, um, I know. I have to look up which article it was. It'll be linked in the show notes, so we will give credit where credit's due. But I could only read an abstract of this one. And the article abstract was vague, and it said it had like 15 participants, and it said that this was included in promising treatment. So do with that what you will. I don't know. I'm not doing anything with it, I guess.

Speaker0:
[29:00] All right. So we've moved through the suprasubglottic, supraglottic swallow. Wow. I always have a hard time with that name. I don't know why. What is our last one?

Speaker1:
[29:12] So our last one is the effortful swallow.

Speaker0:
[29:21] Womp, womp, says Emily.

Speaker1:
[29:24] But which is funny because the, you know, the neurological case didn't actually look at the swallow. But, da-da-da, I found another one.

Speaker0:
[29:39] Give it to me.

Speaker1:
[29:39] So, Baraka et al. completed a study with 30 people who had dysphagia post-stroke and looked at different bolus sizes from 3cc to 10cc. they found that the effortful swallow was more effective in clearing pharyngeal residue. They said...

Speaker0:
[29:56] Can I just say that instinctually, I feel like that makes sense, because if part of what we're trying to deal with with the effortful swallow is a pressure problem, then actually having a larger bolus, I feel like, supports the lack of pressure. You're increasing the size of what is in the airway, in the, oh God, not in the airway, in the pharyngeal space.

Speaker1:
[30:18] Right. Yeah. And that's how we think about it. But when you think about people, we are trying to improve their swallow. The last thing I want to do is give them a big bite, you know.

Speaker0:
[30:30] I know. So scary. So scary. Very.

Speaker1:
[30:33] So it does make sense. If it's heavier, you're automatically going to want to use a stronger swallow to push it down. So it definitely makes sense. It's good that, you know, this study looked at using more volumes to clear pharyngeal residue. So they're not just saying that the effortful swallow was more effective in general at getting material down, but it showed less residue overall left over after the swallow was completed.

Speaker0:
[31:00] Well, I just want to say kudos to the researchers because that's, like you just said, it's a scary thing to want to do. You have a swallow impairment. Let's have you take more food at once. That sounds like a bad idea off the bat. But again, this comes back to what do we know to be effective? Because let's say you're administering a bolus on an instrumental swallow. Your ideal situation comes true. Your patient gets an instrumental swallow study. And then maybe you don't give them enough bolus and the swallow strategies you're trying to teach them don't work. Turns out it's not because it's ineffective, but because we're administering too little bolus because we're afraid to give people food.

Speaker1:
[31:43] Mm-hmm. I love that sound. I don't know what that was.

Speaker0:
[31:52] It was a harumph, you know, for effort, for emphasis, I guess.

Speaker0:
[32:03] Anyways, moving on to our third article of the day, which is secretly like the fifth article of the day.

Speaker1:
[32:09] The air quotes around that were heavy.

Speaker0:
[32:14] All right. And this one looked at post-cancer patients, right? By McCabe.

Speaker1:
[32:19] Right. So going through the list, starting with the chin tuck. And they looked at 26 participants who were post-esophagectomy. With oropharyngeal dysphagia who were aspirating thin liquids, thick liquids.

Speaker0:
[32:37] Amperes, all the stuff. It was all making people go.

Speaker1:
[32:43] So this one, they wanted to, they like made a little asterisk in the study that these people didn't technically have an oropharyngeal cancer. They had esophageal cancer. So they were just saying like maybe this is not... Yeah, maybe this is not going to be. If you're going to put additional punctuation,

Speaker0:
[33:07] It better be a good used asterisk.

Speaker1:
[33:09] It was easy. Yeah. So it's a related cancer, not the same. So if we're looking at head and neck cancer, we're diving deep into the neck.

Speaker0:
[33:20] We're getting deep in there. Okay, wait. So we had said that they were aspirating on all kinds of things. Thins, thick, puree. and that the chin tuck eliminated aspiration in like 17 out of 21 participants. Well done, chin tuck for esophageal cancer.

Speaker1:
[33:38] Right. Second one, Mendelssohn. So this maneuver facilitated complete base of tongue contact with the posterior pharyngeal wall.

Speaker0:
[33:49] That base of tongue is getting all up on the back of your throat.

Speaker1:
[33:52] All up on there. And it increased the duration of the contact. So all of the things that we kind of saw in the normal swallow that was happening that we loved also happened in these populations that we love. So for these participants, 80% of them increased oral intake by at least one point on the FOIS scale. So before using the Mendelssohn, maybe they were a 2 or a 3. After starting this Mendelssohn, maybe they were a 3 or 4.

Speaker0:
[34:25] And just in case you don't know, the, FOIS, I'm going to go. It's F-O-I-S, scale. It's a ranking system for somebody's eating. Like, are they allowed to take anything in my mouth? Are they tube feed dependent? Are they completely fine? No notes. Or are they somewhere in the middle? Like, they can eat fine, but you got to make some adjustments. So if you're moving up on the scale, you're getting closer and closer to independent eating, which is great.

Speaker1:
[34:54] Yep and they out of the 12 people that were on a non-oral diet three progressed to an oral feeding diet so You know, it's still not a lot, the study, not super big, but, you know, even one more person getting off completely two feet is progress.

Speaker0:
[35:15] So, yep.

Speaker1:
[35:18] Next one, the head turn. This study did not do it.

Speaker0:
[35:23] Can I, I'm just going to go out on a limb here and say that you maybe looked up another study.

Speaker1:
[35:28] You know, you are so smart.

Speaker0:
[35:33] I'm teachable.

Speaker1:
[35:35] But the only thing that I really could find was one on cervical osteophytes. And I thought like, maybe that's like growth in the way-esque of cancer. I don't know. I couldn't find anything that was cancer related to using a head turn. Cervical osteophytes were the only one. And in this, I found a study by CO et al. and they reported that the head turn away from the osteophyte was beneficial for 10 out of 48 patients with dysphagia due to those osteophytes.

Speaker0:
[36:10] All right well I'll take your generalization for cancer to other anatomical structural changes with osteophytes. I would love to see the research on whether or not that's actually a usable generalization. Yeah. Go out there researchers figure it out but did they do a effortful swallow yeah, On the original research article, they didn't do the supraglottic, but did they do an effortful swallow?

Speaker1:
[36:38] So they didn't do a head turn.

Speaker0:
[36:40] Oh, sorry. They didn't do a head turn.

Speaker1:
[36:42] They didn't do a head turn. They looked at the supraglottic swallow and found that patients with head and neck cancer benefited more from other treatments. So, like, they said, eh.

Speaker0:
[36:53] All right. So they did it. Not great.

Speaker1:
[36:57] Yeah. They're like, it's fine. Like, if you want to. Like if you want to text me, like I won't mind, but like you don't have to.

Speaker0:
[37:10] And just remember, if you are dosing and prescribing exercises, remember that your patient probably won't do them all. So if it's sort of a, only text me if you want to, maybe don't if there are other better options. Right.

Speaker1:
[37:24] We keep our options open. And the last one is the effortful swallow. So compared to all of the other maneuvers studied, the effortful swallow produced the most base of tongue contraction and the most pharyngeal pressure with these patients, which is significant because if we are needing pressure, if we have, let's say, radiation swelling and things are sticking or not wanting to move very good because everything else is just more bulbous than it was before, Or having more effort to get those down is probably exactly what these people need.

Speaker0:
[38:01] Yeah, that's a good one. When you say, how do you like your meals? You like them with the most posterior pharyngeal wall pressure.

Speaker1:
[38:10] With bacon on the side.

Speaker0:
[38:11] And with bacon on the side. At the amount of times people are always like, why can't I have bacon? I'm like, because of the sodium and the fat and the things you're not allowed to eat here in the hospital because you had a stroke. Sorry. Maybe bacon when you go home.

Speaker1:
[38:28] Don't tell. You can have bacon if I'm like, la, la, la, la, la, la.

Speaker0:
[38:33] If I see no evil, hear no evil, you can have bacon. So while we're zooming out and we're looking at that bigger picture of all, of everything that this trio of research is looking at, what do we want to say that they're claiming?

Speaker1:
[38:51] We're looking at the giant big picture. We are saying that while our normal healthy swallows showed a lot of things and a lot of great things that were theorized to happen, they are not universally applicable to our dysphagia patients. And what we need to do is make sure that we are providing appropriate compensations or thinking about appropriate compensations to the demographics that it would actually fit for. instead of using 20-year-old data. That was wrong when I went to school.

Speaker0:
[39:38] Well, just circling back to earlier in our conversation, I think what you were listing at the beginning, even though it can sometimes really sound tedious to read or, in y'all's case, listen to, is understanding, like truly understanding what these swallow compensatory strategies are supposed to do, understanding increased pressure within the pharyngeal cavity, understanding that there's a required point of contact between base of tongue and posterior pharyngeal wall. Knowing these things and how our compensatory strategies support them is really important when you're looking at your patient's impairments and trying to select which of these is appropriate for my patient. Understanding what their diagnosis is and trying to recognize what has actually been trialed for this population versus what do I just maybe I'm gonna throw some like compensatory spaghetti at the wall and see what sticks. And I just wanted to say thank you for really getting into the weeds with this because this is such a key aspect in what we're doing for dysphagia rehabilitation. And now getting back to those fundamentals of a swallowing compensatory strategies, we really can't be doing that right.

Speaker1:
[40:56] Right. And it is, it's honestly half of what we should be doing. Like if we are working on someone's swallow, we should 100% be doing swallowing exercises to improve that swallow where we can. And then using a compensation in the meantime to see if we can make quality of life better until we can get their swallow you know more functional like what so Another reason I kind of dug into this was because of our new friend, Chantel.

Speaker0:
[41:29] She's so cute. She was like, I love talking with new speechies. I was like, that makes me feel adorable to be a speechy.

Speaker1:
[41:38] But she is the founder and creator of Dysphagia Bites, if you've seen her Instagram, and she has her own podcast. but she has a page on her website that lists off a bunch of different cups that are meant to help with a chin tuck and i had only learned of two of them before i saw that paper and i think that there's six on there so It really sometimes feels like when we're in the skilled nursing world, we are so segmented off in a way that we have to learn everything by experience or by somebody else's experience to those things. So seeing that on her website was like, wow, these are things that I could have tried with my population had I known they existed. So that was another reason I was like, I need to, we need to get into it. We need to share it with you guys because I would have liked to know.

Speaker0:
[42:28] Yeah. And of course, Emily did something amazing. She made a chart for y'all, which you can use as a refresher on which compensatory strategies can be helpful with certain patient populations.

Speaker1:
[42:41] Yep.

Speaker0:
[42:42] And as always, our favorite topic, the intersection of cognition and dysphagia. Don't count out our dementia patients because apparently swallowing strategies, are effective for them too.

Speaker1:
[42:55] Yeah, they definitely can. And they could use them. Even if they're not going to remember to tuck their chin, if you give them a cup where they have to tuck their chin to use it, bada-boom, bada-bing. You did it.

Speaker0:
[43:06] You did it.

Speaker1:
[43:07] You win.

Speaker0:
[43:08] Don't. Yeah.

Speaker1:
[43:08] So.

Speaker0:
[43:09] Everybody else gets to use devices. So do we. Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker1:
[43:14] We get a budget, too.

Speaker0:
[43:16] I've never been included in rehab budget discussions. It was like, speech, you don't need anything, right? No. You don't need anything? Cool, cool, cool. Moving on.

Speaker1:
[43:25] A Lark box? We have a Lark box for you. Like, oh, thanks.

Speaker0:
[43:29] I made my own Lark box before I knew what they were. For those of you who don't know, it's a box of stuff. And I had just been making my own. I had just been like collecting things that were lost in the rehab gym. I was like, this is a pair of underwear. What is it? Oh, no. Underwear.

Speaker1:
[43:47] Do you really have underwear in your Lark box?

Speaker0:
[43:50] There were a pair of boxers in there. What?

Speaker1:
[43:55] That's funny.

Speaker0:
[43:57] Anyway. All right.

Speaker1:
[43:58] That's our whole episode. Eva, do you have any more takeaways? Your last takeaway was beautiful.

Speaker0:
[44:05] Last summation, takeaways, just that we will keep working on making sure that we are trying to find good dysphagia information. Because as Emily said, we're so cut off from what is going on if you're the only speech therapist in the house. And making sure that we're trying to bring that to you guys is important to us. So thanks again to Emily for this awesome side-by-side. And until next time, stay curious, stay skeptical, and we'll see you. Or you'll see us. Just kidding, it's all audio.

Speaker1:
[44:45] Unless you come to Instagram. You've been listening to Speech Talk.

Speaker0:
[44:50] Thank you, everyone, for coming to listen to our research book club. Until next time, keep learning and leading with research.

Speaker1:
[44:56] If you like this episode and you want to give us some love, please rate us on your favorite podcasting app. Leave a review and tell the world, because as podcasters, our love language is in positive affirmations.

Speaker0:
[45:08] And if you like listening to us, you may like more podcasts from our network, Human Content, like how to be patient, bendy bodies, knock knock high with the glock and fleckens, and psychiatry bootcamp. If you have a research topic you want us to cover, or you have episode comments, clinical experience you want to share, or just want to send us some love letters, send us an email at hello at speechtalkpod.com.

Speaker1:
[45:32] If you want even more speech talk content, check out our website at speechtalkpod.com, where you can find all of our resources we made for you, copies of articles covered, and Eva's blog following these topics and more.

Speaker0:
[45:45] We're your hosts, Eva Johnson and Emily Brady.

Speaker1:
[45:47] Our editor and engineer is Andrew Sims.

Speaker0:
[45:50] Our music is by Omar Ben-Zvi.

Speaker1:
[45:52] Our executive producers are Aaron Corney, Rob Goldman, and Shanti Brooke.

Speaker0:
[45:57] To learn about Speech Talk's program disclaimer and ethics policy, verification and licensing terms, and HIPAA release terms, you can go to speechtalkpod.com slash disclaimers.

Speaker1:
[46:09] Speech Talk is a proud member of the Human Content Podcast Network.